As the Cincinnati Bengals navigate the complex landscape of the upcoming offseason, their primary focus remains on retaining key internal free agents. Yet, discussions are emerging around the possible reunion with former roster members. Among these names, Mike Hilton, a veteran cornerback, stands out as a noteworthy candidate, offering the team an opportunity to bolster its defensive unit with experienced talent.
Mike Hilton, who will celebrate his 32nd birthday in March, is poised to enter the open market. He is currently recognized by Pro Football Focus (PFF) as the 58th overall player in the pool of impending free agents. His tenure with the Bengals, which concluded recently, saw him establish himself as a highly effective slot cornerback. During his time from 2021 to 2024, Hilton impressively recorded 138 defensive stops, a figure that placed him among the league's elite at his position. Furthermore, in the 2024 season, he achieved a remarkable 91.7 PFF run-defense grade, leading all qualified defenders. Although he experienced a shoulder injury, his past performance suggests he could still be a significant contributor to any team.
While Hilton's performance seemed to decline towards the end of his last stint with the Bengals, his specialized skills remained valuable. The departure of defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo, under whom Hilton previously excelled, marks a new chapter for the team's defense. Nevertheless, considering the Bengals' ongoing need for assistance in the slot and near the line of scrimmage, bringing Hilton back should not be dismissed. The team already has Dax Hill and DJ Turner solidified in boundary cornerback positions, but the slot and safety spots under Al Golden's defensive scheme are areas targeted for potential upgrades this offseason. Hilton could provide crucial depth, ready to step in when needed.
Beyond his on-field contributions, Hilton also presents an opportunity to address a long-standing leadership vacuum within the Bengals' defense. While younger players are gradually stepping up, reintroducing Hilton into the locker room could provide an immediate boost in terms of veteran presence and guidance. Such a move, offering both practical playing utility and intangible leadership, represents a strategic option for the Bengals as they plan for the upcoming season, indicating that the concept of bringing back the seasoned cornerback holds merit.